Quem é autoritário?


O colunista da Folha de S. Paulo, Hélio Schwartsman, escreveu ontem que os estudantes que ocuparam suas escolas no Paraná estão sendo… autoritários!

Em que consiste esse “abuso” da parte de jovens secundaristas, na opinião do “sábio” colunista? Impedir que seus colegas tenham aulas para que seu protesto contra a PEC 241 e a MP do ensino médio seja ouvido.

É a mesma reclamação, já centenária, dos patrões contra os trabalhadores grevistas. Os petroleiros não podem cruzar os braços porque o povo vai ficar sem gás de cozinha. Os eletricitários vão deixar todos no escuro. Os carteiros, pilhas de cartas e encomendas. Os condutores de trens e ônibus impedirão milhões de irem e virem. As passeatas atrapalham o trânsito…

A greve impede a “produção” dos bondosos patrões (mais especificamente, impede a produção dos demais assalariados, já que patrões, por definição, nada produzem). Por essa lógica, o protesto impede a democracia.

Nesse caso, como ocorre quase sempre com a “liberal” Folha de S. Paulo, o interesse capitalista, reacionário, vem coberto de um verniz esquerdista, democratizante.

Schwartsman acusa os estudantes de não serem solidários com os colegas que querem ter aulas ou fazer o Enem, mas… acha importante que os estudantes se envolvam com política.

Ele considera que, embora protestar contra a reforma educacional seja justo – porque a voz (e a força) dos estudantes “precisa ser ouvida” – esse protesto é vão, desnecessário porque está desorientado. Os estudantes que protestam não são tão sábios quanto um filósofo do quilate de Schwartsman, que escreve seus conselhos coberto pela autoridade moral da Folha de S. Paulo.

Mas o que Schwartsman não explica é que, se os estudantes estão apenas protestando, por que é que eles são autoritários, e não a polícia, que reprimiu duramente esses protestos?

Embutida na defesa do “direito democrático” de terem aulas e fazer provas está a defesa do Estado autoritário e repressivo, do seu braço armado, herança da ditadura militar. A acusação dirigida aos estudantes, nesse caso, fala o suficiente de quem os acusa. Trata-se de calar o protesto para deixar que soem apenas as bombas, os tiros e os gritos dos oprimidos.

artigo Anterior

Mais uma capitulação! “Oposição” deixa caminho livre para a destruição do Plano de Saúde dos Correios

Próximo artigo

“Todo mundo adora a Lava Jato”, mas ninguém quer ser Sérgio Moro

Leia mais

159 Comentários

  1. Где в одном месте? А как же avrlib где от UART до FAT и Ethernet.А про либы свои согласен 🙂

  2. why you had the good sense to homeschool your girls.More practically, I'd suggest getting a second oassport, invest overseas in various countries and start moving your assets out of the reach of our beloved government,Make sure you comply with FACTA (foreign account tax compliance act – dont you just love the acronyms!) in that you make sure the IRS knows the exact amounts and where you locate your money overseas. Because it's their right to know these details

  3. Conor – I think the shoe rides great on the road. I can't say that it wears very well, though, because we deliberately put a softer, stickier rubber on the outsole than what was on the 101s (which was quite hard and slick). I do a lot of moderate scrambling on my mountain runs and the softer rubber gives me extra traction/security on rock. The trade-off, however, is that it's not quite as durable.

  4. Jan M Fijor pisze:Bank jest magazynem pieniedzy i jesli wlozymy do niego X, to w banku musi byc X. Jesli bedzie mniej, znaczy sie ukradziono nam czesc pieniedzy. jaka kreacja pieniadza? Bank tak robi, ale to grozi upadkiem albo kryzysem. Wyibrazmy sobie, ze w czasie gdy zostawiamy samochod na parkingu ktos z niego korzysta. My o tym nie wiemy, wiec nas glowa nie boli. Podoba sie wam taka kreacja?UklonyJan M Fijor

  5. Come diceva Gaber: "Di loro posso dire solamenteche dalle masse sono riusciti ad ottenerelo stupido pietismo per il carabiniere… E' incredibile, come ad ogni indomani di scontri di piazza, una bella fetta di opinione pubblica si concentri solo ed esclusivamente su questo tema, spostando completamente il fuoco dai veri motivi per cui è successo quel che è successo.Sul serio, siete fantastici.Ma crescete.

  6. A fantastic blog post, I just passed this onto a co-worker who was doing a little analysis on this. And he in fact purchased me dinner because I discovered it for him. .. So let me rephrase that: Thnx for the treat! But yeah Thnx for taking the time to discuss this, I feel strongly about it and love learning more on this topic. If possible, as you gain expertise, would you mind updating your blog with more info? It is extremely helpful for me. Big thumb up for this article!

  7. C’est joli « excrossance », pas très académique, certainement, mais tellement évocateur de 329 ans de Liberté… européenne.Ou 514 ans, si l’on en fait rmonter l’origine à l’Inquisition, non, pardon, à l’expulsion des Juifs d’Espagne, non ! Je me trompe encore : à la découverte de l’Amérique.

  8. I am hopeless with plants and flowers of any kind, but thankfully I have a husband who knows how to make them thrive. I would love to have lemon and orange trees outside my window!I’m going to check out those cheater dumplings. I’m always up for trying any recipe with “cheater” in it, because it means even I can probably pull it off. LOL!Blessings!

  9. I was on holiday in Charlottetown for three weeks and found that my grandparents had been married in the Zion Church on30th November 1922. I am wondering if you have any records of my mother Georgina Lawson Trotter being christened in your church. Apparently they returned here to Scotland in November 1924. My grandfather was Robert Adam Trotter and my grandmother was Isabella Lawson. I found this information in the records office on the street behind the church. I think it was called the ~Cole Building.

  10. I like that you’re under the impression it’s not degrading to slap a woman on the ass. Or that being slapped on the ass makes women feel more comfortable. Or that saving women from aliens means a game doesn’t exploit women. I mean, I know the minigame is a joke and all, but if that’s the kind of attitude you go out and face the world with your’re uh… kind of the type of person people are worried is going to get the wrong impression from it…But just because you asked, I’ll make sure Duke is slapping Fenix’s ass next time.

  11. Camilla, du er så bra. Så bra at du deler dette på bloggen din til oppmuntring, og så spennende at du opplever det du gjør. Håper du finner oppmuntring i å bli avvist og sett stygt på. -det står jo at vi vil møte motstand og vi er salige når vi møter problemer pga vår tro. (Selvom dette knapt kalles motstand, så ville iallefall jeg følt det som å få et slag i trynet de første gangene.)

  12. Good post. I learn something tougher on different blogs everyday. It will all the time be stimulating to learn content material from different writers and follow slightly one thing from their store. I’d want to use some with the content on my blog whether or not you don’t mind. Natually I’ll give you a link in your net blog. Thanks for sharing.

  13. it quite well, especially the part where radicals unilaterally kidnap 'the people' as a term to justify their actions against (big surprise) the people.Democracy is no longer a neutral term, and I can't even bring myself to pronounce that word without being filled with disgust at the actions of those who hijacked it for their arrogant, self-righteous agenda – and especially when they brainwash kids with it.

  14. Skimming through this text I have found solutions for most problems that have been bugging me for long time now. Its difficult to find comprehensible publications on the internet as large portion of the publications are written by someone with only partial knowledge of the topic. Your text is unique and definitively worth recommending. I’ll be returning articles in few days.

  15. Njut av de sista dagarna.. Bra att det känns som att du sku mÃ¥ bra.Jag märkte först efterÃ¥t hur jävla (sorry uttrycket) stor jag var och hur tungt det hade varit.. Det blev liksom sÃ¥ lätt dÃ¥ bebisarna kom ut…och den där tungheten och storheten smög ju sig pÃ¥ sÃ¥ man fattade inte som sagt var före efterÃ¥t hur jobbigt det hade varit

  16. wysman itu merek butter atau mentega. Rada mahal dan wanginya enak Tergantung selera sih zee Browniesku memang di dalamnya agak basah. Itu bukan ndak mateng, tapi memang sengaja dibuat agak basah supaya lekkkkeeer… hehehe. Kalau suka brownies yang kering dan agak keras, tambah saja waktu pemanggangan jadi 15-20 menitan.

  17. Quotidiennement, après avoir descendu la face nord de Montmartre, je prenais le temps de boire un express au comptoir avant de plonger dans le métro. Quotidiennement, à la même heure, un marchand de quatre-saisons de la rue du Poteau hélait le garçon d’un « Albert! Mon chocolat! ».C’était évidemment un code secret entre eux deux : Albert lui servait sans un mot un petit noir et un grand Calva.(comme ça on ne sait pas ce qu’il y a d’dans…)

  18. With all due respect, you are not being clear at all. Please give me the Scriptures you are relying on and please read my post again VERY slowly because you obviously are turning an example into an imperative because you keep bringing it up as a MUST when the post clearly lists it as an example of the radical steps a father SHOULD be willing to take if necessary AND please distinguish between every Christian father’s duty and the duty of a church when dealing with an unrepentant member. Thanks.

  19. Thanks Mike for encapsulating a reasoned and sensible approach to this issue. Sadly, debates like this are too often driven by ignorance and paranoia. I would like to think that we as a community can deal with this issue in an enlightened, sensible and practical manner.Come to think of it, you may be right about Hwy 50 – I’ve noticed lately I always seem to get the munchies driving that way.

  20. Inca n-a nins in NY iarna asta. Vreau sa zic linga NY City, ca in Upstate NY a nins din toi, dar aia-s sub Canada, si e totdeauna frig acolo. “Lake-effect snow” de-ti vine acru de atita zapada.As fi vrut niste zapada ne Craciun, dar a fost cam “caldut”. Mi-au venit niste rude din Canada de Craciun, si aveau gheata pe masina. Brrrrrrr!

  21. Moje najsÅ‚odsze ÅšwiÄ™ta to pierwsze ÅšwiÄ™ta w moim życiu. Mimo, że ich nie pamiÄ™tam wiele o nich sÅ‚yszaÅ‚am a stare slajdy ze ÅšwiÄ…t ze mnÄ… w roli głównej sÄ… czÄ™sto wyÅ›wietlane w moim domu. Moja mama po porodzie wyszÅ‚a ze szpitala 24go grudnia. Ja malutka zostaÅ‚am poÅ‚ożona pod choinkÄ…. ByÅ‚am najlepszym prezentem dla mojej babci (pierwsza wnuczka) oraz rodziców, gdyż byÅ‚am dÅ‚ugo oczekiwanym dzieckiem. Wszyscy nosili mnie na rÄ™kach, przytulali i caÅ‚owali. To byÅ‚o na prawdÄ™ sÅ‚odkie 🙂

  22. My spouse and i buy this kind of costume in my son’s debut in the Malaysia next 12. After i have the object, I feel satisfied along with excited for her. Clothing was over expertly. Oahu is the identical shown on the spot. It’s lovely. We actually check it out to myself to see the way it appears like in the reflect. My partner and i purchase for my most youthful also. I will article this subsequent. I cannot wait for them to wear it to be with her celebration.

  23. It was REAL FUN watching Veena’s Punjabi Stuffed Mammay. Can’t wait to see veena malik JEE in a B Grade indian porn movie getting her arse fcuked in Kama Sutra style by a REAL non-punjabi mard. Paki Punjabis are racist bastards, believe in Caste System, consider their caste to be superior over others. So I hope a Brahamin LORA fcuks Veena’s Gaand Real HARD so her Pendu father could jerk off watching a real MARD fucking her whore of a daughter hardcore …

  24. 1 juillet 2012Who cares if you are locked in for one particular year. That is nothing. I mean actually, what’s another year’s worth of WoW subscription wise? You can continue to play, pay monthly on the other hand you choose according to your billing cycle and you get a bunch of free stuff. You would be nuts not to sign up for that pass. It’s win win. Diablo 3 will more than likely be 60 bucks where I live plus the mount which would be 25 bucks in the Blizz store. 85 bucks worth of free stuff. Why the hell wouldn’t you?  

  25. Creo que todos tenemos la necesidad de ver la pelicula, echamos de menos la serie y a sus personajes, yo vi el spnin off de Joey, pero lo magistral de la serie era el grupo el su conjunto, con 6 caricaturas reales de tipos de personalidad. Debería haber pelicula, pero que no les pased como sexo en nueva york, serie adaptada al cine, o serie adapatada a todos los públicos.En resumen friends en todo su esplendor durante dos horas, que se llegue a filmar eso lo veo más complicado

  26. HeyHowdyWhats upHi thereHeyaHiHey thereHello this is kindasomewhatkind of of off topic but I was wonderingwanting to know if blogs use WYSIWYG editors or if you have to manually code with HTML. I’m starting a blog soon but have no coding knowledgeskillsexperienceknow-howexpertise so I wanted to get adviceguidance from someone with experience. Any help would be greatlyenormously appreciated!

  27. Whats Happening i’m new to this, I stumbled upon this I’ve found It absolutely helpful and it has helped me out loads. I’m hoping to give a contribution & aid other customers like its helped me. Great job.

Deixe uma resposta

O seu endereço de e-mail não será publicado.